Thomas Tuchel deserves to be sacked for his cowardice - The i Paper
Thomas Tuchel deserves to be sacked for his cowardice - The i Paper

England manager Thomas Tuchel has confirmed his intention to remain in his role until Euro 2028, despite the team’s recent World Cup semi-final defeat to Argentina. The Three Lions were eliminated after a 2-1 loss in Atlanta, with Argentina scoring twice late in the match. Tuchel had extended his initial contract earlier this year, securing his position through to the tournament co-hosted by England, Wales, Scotland, and the Republic of Ireland.

The semi-final match saw Anthony Gordon give England the lead before Argentina mounted a comeback. Chelsea‘s Enzo Fernandez and Lautaro Martinez scored the decisive goals, denying England a spot in their first World Cup final since 1966. Tuchel, who was appointed head coach in January 2025, addressed his future directly, stating, “We keep on going with the contract until the home Euros. I’m looking forward to that even though right now it’s difficult to look that far ahead.”

Tactical Decisions Under Scrutiny

Following the defeat, Tuchel’s tactical decisions, particularly in the latter stages of the match, have drawn considerable criticism. Many observers felt England sat too deep and invited pressure after taking the lead. The substitutions made by Tuchel, specifically the introduction of Ezri Konsa for Anthony Gordon and the subsequent shift to a more defensive formation, were highlighted as highly risky. This approach, which saw the team transition to a back six that effectively became a seven or eight, was seen by some as an act of tactical cowardice, especially given the attacking talent available on the bench.

England captain Harry Kane acknowledged that trying to hold onto a 1-0 lead ultimately backfired. He stated that at this level, simply trying to hold on is not enough. Kane indicated that while the message from the coaching staff was to continue pushing for another goal after Gordon’s opener, the team increasingly retreated, allowing Argentina to build pressure. He noted that after the goal, it felt like “wave after wave” of Argentina attacks, which eventually led to their two goals.

The defensive changes implemented by Tuchel throughout the tournament have also been a point of discussion. England utilised three different centre-back pairings, two different starting left-backs, and four different players at right-back, resulting in six different starting back fours. This level of rotation in the defensive line is considered unusual for a major international tournament.

The Road Ahead for England

Despite the disappointment, England will remain in the United States to prepare for a third-place play-off match against France in Miami. Tuchel acknowledged that while it is a game neither team wants to play, reaching the semi-finals for the second time in eight years is an achievement. He emphasised the need for the team to “bounce back and react” at the highest level of sport.

The manager’s appointment was intended to address England‘s past shortcomings in major tournaments, particularly their perceived fear of winning and attacking. Tuchel himself had spoken about the need for England to be brave and play a style reflecting the values of the country and the Premier League. However, the performance against Argentina, where England reportedly had only 12 per cent of the ball between their goal and Argentina‘s winner, and recorded 0.07 xG in 37 minutes, has led to questions about whether the team has truly moved past previous issues.

The defeat has left Harry Kane feeling “gutted,” noting that the team is close to finding the “missing piece” needed to win a major tournament. The focus now shifts to the upcoming Euro 2028, which will be co-hosted by England, Wales, Scotland, and the Republic of Ireland.

The team will face France in Miami on Saturday for the third-place play-off.

Read Also

Source: inews.co.uk

George Hartwell

George Hartwell

Senior Football Correspondent

George Hartwell is the Senior Football Correspondent at News-GB.org, covering the Premier League, the EFL and the England national side with twelve years of reporting experience. He reported on West Country football before national coverage. He holds a degree in Sports Journalism from the University of the West of England and completed an NCTJ diploma. Based in Bristol, he watches grassroots football and writes a tactics column. “Tactics tell you more than any scoreline.”